As the CDC shifts masking guidance, Americans are split on path forward

Most adults in the United States are getting back to some degree of pre-pandemic normalcy, but they’re divided over concerns and expectations for what’s next.

Three surveys conducted in February – from the Kaiser Family Foundation, Axios/Ipsos and the Washington Post in collaboration with ABC News – asked adults to assess the current state of the pandemic in the United States.

Only a third of adults think the virus is “completely” or “mostly” under control, according to the Post/ABC survey. But most think the worst is behind them, the KFF survey found.

And the Biden administration isn’t getting much credit. Less than half of adults say that the President has communicated clearly or supported health care workers or small businesses during the pandemic, according to Axios/Ipsos.

The polls were each fielded before the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention shifted the metrics it uses for masking guidance and rolled back universal indoor masking recommendations from nearly everyone to less than 30% of the country’s population.

A customer waiting to enter a restaurant holds a protective mask in San Francisco, California, U.S., on Wednesday, Feb. 16, 2022. The states indoor mask requirement, which requires everyone to wear face coverings indoors regardless of vaccination status, expired on Wednesday, with officials pointing to falling Covid-19 case counts and relatively low hospitalizations rates during the omicron surge as reasons for the change, reports the San Francisco Chronicle. Photographer: David Paul Morris/Bloomberg via Getty Images

Related article New CDC Covid-19 metrics drop strong mask recommendations for most of the country

But even before that shift in federal guidance, less than a third of adults said that they are still wearing a mask at all times outside the home, according to Axios/Ipsos. Fewer are social distancing, and more are eating out and visiting family and friends, too.

At this stage of the pandemic, behaviors and opinions on masking and other restrictions aimed to minimize the spread are mixed – with a split largely down party lines.

Republicans are much more likely than Democrats to say that they are already back to normal, the polls found.

Support for a strategy that would move toward normal with precautions in place has gained support in recent weeks, the Axios/Ipsos survey found. But while more than a quarter of adults say that there should be no mandates or requirements, more than one in five say that these requirements should increase.

Overall in the US, a majority of adults are concerned about the consequences of lifting restrictions and keeping them in place, according to the KFF survey. But Democrats are far more likely to say they are concerned about the negative effects of lifting restrictions, while Republicans were more likely to be concerned about the negative effects of keeping restrictions in place.

More than 80% of Democrats said they were at least “somewhat” worried that immunocompromised people will be left behind if the government lifts masking restrictions, compared with 30% of Republicans. Democrats were also about three times more likely than Republicans to say that lifting restrictions could lead to more deaths in their community or cause hospitals to become overwhelmed.

About three-quarters of Republicans, meanwhile, said they worry that local businesses would suffer due to loss of revenue, compared with 50% of Democrats.

A majority of both Democrats (56%) and Republicans (73%) said they are worried that the mental health of kids and teenagers will suffer if restrictions are kept in place.

Red and blue states alike have started to lift mask mandates and roll back other pandemic-related restrictions such as vaccination requirements.

The new CDC recommendations, released Friday, also apply to schools.

People walking through Herald Square wear protective face masks while others do not outdoors in New York, NY, on February 23, 2022. New York Gov. Hochul lifted the indoor mask requirement on February 9, but statewide mask requirements are still in effect at correctional facilities, schools & childcare centers, homeless shelters, buses, trains and transportation hubs. (Photo by Anthony Behar/Sipa USA)(Sipa via AP Images)

Related article A slew of states, cities and schools are ditching mask mandates this week. But the fate of one big mandate is still up in air

Support for masks in schools has fallen since the start of the school year, and parents are now split on the issue, according to the KFF survey.

In September, more than 60% of parents favored some level of masking requirements in school. Now, 43% say masks should be required for all students and staff, 46% say there should be no requirement at all, and 9% say masks should be required only for the unvaccinated in schools.

The partisan divide is clear, with two-thirds of Democrats in support of universal masking requirements in schools and more than three-quarters of Republicans in favor of removing mask requirements completely in schools.

And as masking guidance shifts, vaccinations stagnate.

The KFF survey was fielded right as the US Food and Drug Administration postponed making a decision on whether to authorize a Pfizer/BioNTech vaccine for emergency use among children ages 6 months through 4 years.

Nearly 40% of parents of children younger than 5 said that communication from federal health agencies about vaccines for this age group has been confusing. Most say they don’t have enough information about their safety and effectiveness, and more than two-thirds say they are not confident that Covid-19 vaccines are safe for young children.

An eight-year-old child receives the Pfizer-BioNTech Covid-19 vaccine for 5 to 11-year-old kids in Hartford, Connecticut.

Related article Pfizer Covid-19 vaccine effectiveness fell quickly for kids during Omicron surge but still offered some protection against severe disease

Only about 1 in 5 parents of children younger than 5 says they plan to get their child vaccinated right away once they are eligible, according to the KFF survey.

About a third of children ages 5 to 11 are already vaccinated. But parents of another third of kids in this age group say that they will “definitely not” get their child vaccinated.

On Monday, new data from the New York State Department of Health showed that vaccine effectiveness waned quickly during the Omicron surge, especially among children ages 5 to 11, but was still protective against severe disease.

The authors of the preprint study concluded that if other studies repeat these findings, the vaccine dose for younger children may need to be reviewed. The authors also said the data may demonstrate a need to continue “layered protections, including mask wearing, to prevent infection and transmission” in younger children.

The KFF survey found that vaccination rates are higher for older children, with about 57% of children ages 12 to 17 vaccinated. But parents of another 30% say they will “definitely not” get their adolescent vaccinated.

Overall, vaccination rates among adults have remained largely unchanged, with only about half receiving a booster shot.

Yet more than a third of adults say it’s safe to return to pre-pandemic activities.

This is especially true among Republicans (65%) and unvaccinated adults (60%), but it’s far less common among Democrats (11%) and vaccinated adults (26%). Only a quarter of adults say it will be at least another year before it will be safe to return to normal.

The vast majority of those surveyed said “normal” life will be different going forward, including continued mask wearing, continued precautions, changes to the way we work and social distancing.