"
data-check-event-based-preview=""
data-is-vertical-video-embed="false"
data-network-id=""
data-publish-date="2018-10-23T17:36:57Z"
data-video-section="health"
data-canonical-url="https://www.cnn.com/videos/health/2018/10/22/giving-birth-maternal-care-california-orig.cnn"
data-branding-key=""
data-video-slug="giving birth maternal care california orig"
data-first-publish-slug="giving birth maternal care california orig"
data-video-tags="arts and entertainment,business and industry sectors,business, economy and trade,california,consumer products,continents and regions,families and children,food and drink,food products,fruit,fruits and vegetables,health and health care (by demographic group),health and medical,health care,immigration,immigration, citizenship and displacement,international relations and national security,kinds of foods and beverages,maternal and child health,medical fields and specialties,movies,north america,obstetrics and gynecology,parents and parenting,pregnancy and childbirth,society,southwestern united states,the americas,united states,women's health"
data-details="">
"
data-check-event-based-preview=""
data-is-vertical-video-embed="false"
data-network-id=""
data-publish-date="2017-11-13T21:22:49Z"
data-video-section="health"
data-canonical-url="https://www.cnn.com/videos/health/2017/11/13/mother-birth-america-louisiana-orig.cnn"
data-branding-key=""
data-video-slug="mother birth america louisiana orig"
data-first-publish-slug="mother birth america louisiana orig"
data-video-tags="accidents, disasters and safety,baton rouge,floods and flooding,health and medical,louisiana,maternal and child health,medical fields and specialties,natural disasters,north america,obstetrics and gynecology,pregnancy and childbirth,southeastern united states,united states,women's health"
data-details="">
"
data-check-event-based-preview=""
data-is-vertical-video-embed="false"
data-network-id=""
data-publish-date="2018-06-18T15:53:24Z"
data-video-section="tv"
data-canonical-url="https://www.cnn.com/videos/tv/2018/06/18/bolduan-every-mother-counts-champions.cnn"
data-branding-key="champions-for-change"
data-video-slug="bolduan every mother counts champions"
data-first-publish-slug="bolduan every mother counts champions"
data-video-tags="kate bolduan,parents and parenting,society,business and industry sectors,business, economy and trade,health and medical,health care"
data-details="">
"
data-check-event-based-preview=""
data-is-vertical-video-embed="false"
data-network-id=""
data-publish-date="2015-12-11T22:16:33Z"
data-video-section="tv"
data-canonical-url="https://www.cnn.com/videos/tv/2015/12/11/turlington-giving-birth-in-america-brooke-baldwin.cnn"
data-branding-key=""
data-video-slug="turlington giving birth in america brooke baldwin"
data-first-publish-slug="turlington giving birth in america brooke baldwin"
data-video-tags="celebrities,centers for disease control and prevention,christy turlington,government and public administration,government bodies and offices,health and medical,health departments,maternal and child health,medical fields and specialties,national institutes of health,obstetrics and gynecology,pregnancy and childbirth,public health,us department of health and human services,us federal departments and agencies,women's health,world health organization"
data-details="">
Video Ad Feedback
Two women die each day from childbirth or pregnancy
"
data-check-event-based-preview=""
data-is-vertical-video-embed="false"
data-network-id=""
data-publish-date="2015-11-30T19:36:46Z"
data-video-section="health"
data-canonical-url="https://www.cnn.com/videos/health/2015/11/17/mother-birth-america-florida-orig.cnn"
data-branding-key=""
data-video-slug="mother birth america florida orig"
data-first-publish-slug="mother birth america florida orig"
data-video-tags="business and industry sectors,florida,health and medical,health care,health insurance,insurance,maternal and child health,medical fields and specialties,obstetrics and gynecology,pregnancy and childbirth,southeastern united states,united states,north america,labor and employment,death rates,employment and income status,females (demographic group),health care professionals,low income persons,midwives,population and demographics,population trends,social and economic status,society,underinsured and uninsured health,montana,northwestern united states,business, economy and trade,women's health"
data-details="">
"
data-check-event-based-preview=""
data-is-vertical-video-embed="false"
data-network-id=""
data-publish-date="2015-11-30T19:38:28Z"
data-video-section="health"
data-canonical-url="https://www.cnn.com/videos/health/2015/11/18/mother-birth-america-new-york-orig.cnn"
data-branding-key=""
data-video-slug="mother birth america new york orig"
data-first-publish-slug="mother birth america new york orig"
data-video-tags="labor and employment,employment and income status,females (demographic group),health and medical,low income persons,maternal and child health,medical fields and specialties,new york (state),new york city,north america,northeastern united states,obstetrics and gynecology,population and demographics,pregnancy and childbirth,social and economic status,society,united states,death rates,population trends,women's health"
data-details="">
"
data-check-event-based-preview=""
data-is-vertical-video-embed="false"
data-network-id=""
data-publish-date="2015-11-30T19:38:53Z"
data-video-section="health"
data-canonical-url="https://www.cnn.com/videos/health/2015/11/17/mother-birth-america-montana-orig.cnn"
data-branding-key=""
data-video-slug="mother birth america montana orig"
data-first-publish-slug="mother birth america montana orig"
data-video-tags="health and medical,maternal and child health,medical fields and specialties,montana,north america,northwestern united states,obstetrics and gynecology,pregnancy and childbirth,united states,death rates,population and demographics,population trends,society,business and industry sectors,florida,health care,health care professionals,health insurance,insurance,midwives,southeastern united states,women's health"
data-details="">
"
data-check-event-based-preview=""
data-is-vertical-video-embed="false"
data-network-id=""
data-publish-date="2017-11-15T17:29:42Z"
data-video-section="tv"
data-canonical-url="https://www.cnn.com/videos/tv/2017/11/15/christy-turlington-every-mother-counts-newsroom.cnn"
data-branding-key=""
data-video-slug="christy turlington every mother counts newsroom"
data-first-publish-slug="christy turlington every mother counts newsroom"
data-video-tags="celebrities,christy turlington,death rates,health and medical,maternal and child health,medical fields and specialties,obstetrics and gynecology,population and demographics,population trends,pregnancy and childbirth,society,women's health,business and industry sectors,business, economy and trade,health care"
data-details="">
Pregnancy-related deaths in Texas doubled in two years, a 2016 study showed
A new study refutes the data, blaming the discrepancy on human error
CNN
—
The maternal mortality rate in Texas inspired headlines in 2016 when a study reported that pregnancy-related deaths there had more than doubled in just two years.
A new study published in the same medical journal tamps down the alarm, offering different data that reduce the number of deaths by nearly two-thirds.
Researchers with the Texas Department of State Health Services set out to evaluate the original findings published in the journal of Obstetrics & Gynecology, which, they say, showed 147 maternal deaths in their state in 2012, an unprecedented increase from 2010, 72 deaths. The 2012 number was significant enough to inspire legislative efforts, including the establishment and extension of a maternal mortality and morbidity task force.
What researchers found upon further analysis, which included examinations of medical and autopsy records, was that there were actually 56 – not 147 – maternal deaths in 2012. Human error while using an electronic death registration system appears to have been the biggest culprit in the discrepancy.
Electronic filing of death certificates by doctors, justices of the peace and medical examiners grew 44% in Texas from 2010 to 2012, researchers found. Those who filed the certificates most likely clicked on the wrong dropdown menu option when entering pregnancy status, thereby suggesting that more than twice the number of deceased women were pregnant upon their deaths when they were not.
“Other academic research has shown issues with the quality of death data, nationally,” said the new study’s lead author, Sonia Baeva, a maternal mortality and morbidity epidemiologist with the Texas Department of State Health Services, in a statement. “Death data can be a rich source of information, but our work shows that identification of rare events, such as maternal deaths, should be supported with additional evidence.”
The new study takes some heat off Texas, which state Sen. Lois Kolkhorst applauded in a statement.
“It is clear that Texas does not have the worst maternal mortality in the developed world and that previous reports were grossly inaccurate,” said Kolkhorst, who authored State Bill 17 in 2017to extend the maternal mortality and morbidity task force. “Instead of overreacting to sensationalized reports in the media, we directed better data collection in order to develop targeted, evidence-based strategies to more effectively improve the lives and health of mothers in Texas.”
The lead author of the 2016 study is all for accurate data, but she clarifies that a followup study should have never been necessary in the first place.
Marian MacDorman of the Maryland Population Research Center explained that the data she and her co-authors worked with were drawn directly from the Vital Statistics Division of the Texas Department of Health, which – as in all 50 states – passed its information along to the National Center for Health Statistics.
Join the conversation
See the latest news and share your comments with CNN Health on Facebook and Twitter.
“The conflict is not really between data from ‘my’ study and ‘their’ study,” she said. “The conflict is that the Vital Statistics section of the Texas Department of Health has different numbers from the Texas maternal mortality review task force.
“It’s appropriate that they did the study, given that the data was so bad,” she said, “but basically they shouldn’t have to do this kind of study.”
Time spent correcting counts in a data system takes away from maternal health work itself, MacDorman said. Her hope is that Texas can now focus on the women who need health services.