"
data-check-event-based-preview=""
data-is-vertical-video-embed="false"
data-network-id=""
data-publish-date="2018-08-10T08:31:54Z"
data-video-section="world"
data-canonical-url="https://www.cnn.com/videos/world/2018/08/10/chinese-militarization-south-china-sea-lkl-vpx.cnn"
data-branding-key=""
data-video-slug="chinese militarization south china sea lkl vpx"
data-first-publish-slug="chinese militarization south china sea lkl vpx"
data-video-tags="aircraft,aviation and aerospace industry,border control,business and industry sectors,business, economy and trade,international relations,international relations and national security,ivan watson,military,military aircraft,misc people,national security,oceans and seas (by name),physical locations,south china sea,surveillance and reconnaissance aircraft,territorial and national borders,asia,china,continents and regions,east asia"
data-details="">
"
data-check-event-based-preview=""
data-is-vertical-video-embed="false"
data-network-id=""
data-publish-date="2018-08-10T08:31:54Z"
data-video-section="world"
data-canonical-url="https://www.cnn.com/videos/world/2018/08/10/chinese-militarization-south-china-sea-lkl-vpx.cnn"
data-branding-key=""
data-video-slug="chinese militarization south china sea lkl vpx"
data-first-publish-slug="chinese militarization south china sea lkl vpx"
data-video-tags="aircraft,aviation and aerospace industry,border control,business and industry sectors,business, economy and trade,international relations,international relations and national security,ivan watson,military,military aircraft,misc people,national security,oceans and seas (by name),physical locations,south china sea,surveillance and reconnaissance aircraft,territorial and national borders,asia,china,continents and regions,east asia"
data-details="">
"
data-check-event-based-preview=""
data-is-vertical-video-embed="false"
data-network-id=""
data-publish-date="2018-10-03T07:15:58Z"
data-video-section="world"
data-canonical-url="https://www.cnn.com/videos/world/2018/10/03/us-china-destroyers-confrontation-south-china-sea-jiang-sot-vpx.cnni"
data-branding-key=""
data-video-slug="us china destroyers confrontation south china sea jiang sot vpx"
data-first-publish-slug="us china destroyers confrontation south china sea jiang sot vpx"
data-video-tags="business and industry sectors,business, economy and trade,government and public administration,government bodies and offices,government organizations - us,marine transportation,marine vessels,military,military vessels,oceans and seas (by name),physical locations,south china sea,transportation and warehousing,us department of defense,us federal departments and agencies,us federal government,us navy"
data-details="">
"
data-check-event-based-preview=""
data-is-vertical-video-embed="false"
data-network-id=""
data-publish-date="2018-08-10T23:56:03Z"
data-video-section="world"
data-canonical-url="https://www.cnn.com/videos/world/2018/08/10/us-navy-plane-warned-south-china-sea-watson-dnt-vpx.cnn"
data-branding-key=""
data-video-slug="us navy plane warned south china sea watson dnt vpx"
data-first-publish-slug="us navy plane warned south china sea watson dnt vpx"
data-video-tags="border control,government and public administration,government bodies and offices,government organizations - us,international relations,ivan watson,misc people,national security,oceans and seas (by name),physical locations,south china sea,territorial and national borders,us department of defense,us federal departments and agencies,us federal government,us navy,international relations and national security"
data-details="">
"
data-check-event-based-preview=""
data-is-vertical-video-embed="false"
data-network-id=""
data-publish-date="2016-09-29T05:17:03Z"
data-video-section="world"
data-canonical-url="https://www.cnn.com/videos/world/2016/09/29/kristie-lu-stout-south-china-sea-graphic-explainer.cnn"
data-branding-key=""
data-video-slug="Kristie Lu Stout South China Sea graphic explainer"
data-first-publish-slug="Kristie Lu Stout South China Sea graphic explainer"
data-video-tags=""
data-details="">
"
data-check-event-based-preview=""
data-is-vertical-video-embed="false"
data-network-id=""
data-publish-date="2017-07-02T10:33:54Z"
data-video-section="world"
data-canonical-url="https://www.cnn.com/videos/world/2017/07/02/us-navy-south-china-sea-newday.cnn"
data-branding-key=""
data-video-slug="US Navy South China Sea Newday"
data-first-publish-slug="US Navy South China Sea Newday"
data-video-tags="asia,business and industry sectors,business, economy and trade,china,east asia,government and public administration,government bodies and offices,marine transportation,marine vessels,military,military vessels,south china sea,transportation and warehousing,us department of defense,us federal departments and agencies,us federal government,us navy"
data-details="">
"
data-check-event-based-preview=""
data-is-vertical-video-embed="false"
data-network-id=""
data-publish-date="2017-02-19T10:50:18Z"
data-video-section="world"
data-canonical-url="https://www.cnn.com/videos/world/2017/02/19/us-carrier-south-china-sea-uss-carl-vinson-defterious.cnn"
data-branding-key=""
data-video-slug="us carrier south china sea uss carl vinson defterious"
data-first-publish-slug="us carrier south china sea uss carl vinson defterious"
data-video-tags="business and industry sectors,business, economy and trade,international relations,international relations and national security,marine transportation,marine vessels,military,military vessels,north america,south china sea,territorial and national borders,transportation and warehousing,united states"
data-details="">
"
data-check-event-based-preview=""
data-is-vertical-video-embed="false"
data-network-id=""
data-publish-date="2016-12-15T11:27:59Z"
data-video-section="world"
data-canonical-url="https://www.cnn.com/videos/world/2016/12/15/trump-china-whats-at-stake-sfc-orig.cnn"
data-branding-key=""
data-video-slug="trump china whats at stake sfc orig"
data-first-publish-slug="trump china whats at stake sfc orig"
data-video-tags="asia,china,east asia,government and public administration,government bodies and offices,military,us federal government,white house,donald trump,political figures - us,business, economy and trade,economy and economic indicators,north korea,south china sea"
data-details="">
"
data-check-event-based-preview=""
data-is-vertical-video-embed="false"
data-network-id=""
data-publish-date="2017-03-06T08:24:31Z"
data-video-section="world"
data-canonical-url="https://www.cnn.com/videos/world/2017/03/06/chinas-role-with-north-korea-rivers-pkg.cnn"
data-branding-key=""
data-video-slug="china's role with north korea rivers pkg"
data-first-publish-slug="china's role with north korea rivers pkg"
data-video-tags="asia,china,disability and society,diseases and disorders,donald trump,ear, nose and throat disorders,east asia,government and public administration,government bodies and offices,health and medical,hearing impairment,kim jong un,military,military weapons,north korea,north korea nuclear development,political figures - intl,political figures - us,society,us federal government,weapons and arms,white house"
data-details="">
"
data-check-event-based-preview=""
data-is-vertical-video-embed="false"
data-network-id=""
data-publish-date="2017-01-13T23:20:09Z"
data-video-section="politics"
data-canonical-url="https://www.cnn.com/videos/politics/2017/01/13/tillerson-south-china-sea-todd-tsr-dnt.cnn"
data-branding-key=""
data-video-slug="tillerson south china sea todd tsr dnt"
data-first-publish-slug="tillerson south china sea todd tsr dnt"
data-video-tags="business figures,government and public administration,government bodies and offices,international relations,international relations and national security,rex tillerson,south china sea,state departments and diplomatic services,unrest, conflicts and war,cabinet nominees,us federal government"
data-details="">
"
data-check-event-based-preview=""
data-is-vertical-video-embed="false"
data-network-id=""
data-publish-date="2016-07-12T23:24:32Z"
data-video-section="world"
data-canonical-url="https://www.cnn.com/videos/world/2016/07/12/beijing-rejects-south-china-sea-ruling-lklv-rivers.cnn"
data-branding-key=""
data-video-slug="beijing rejects south china sea ruling lklv rivers"
data-first-publish-slug="beijing rejects south china sea ruling lklv rivers"
data-video-tags="asia,beijing,china,decisions and rulings,east asia,international courts and tribunals,law and legal system,law courts and tribunals,south china sea,trial and procedure"
data-details="">
"
data-check-event-based-preview=""
data-is-vertical-video-embed="false"
data-network-id=""
data-publish-date="2016-05-24T06:54:46Z"
data-video-section="world"
data-canonical-url="https://www.cnn.com/videos/world/2016/05/24/obama-big-nations-not-bully-small-ones-sot.cnn"
data-branding-key=""
data-video-slug="obama big nations not bully small ones sot"
data-first-publish-slug="obama big nations not bully small ones sot"
data-video-tags="asia,barack obama,business, economy and trade,company activities and management,company structure and ownership,entrepreneurship,hanoi,political figures - us,south china sea,southeast asia,vietnam"
data-details="">
Video Ad Feedback
President Obama: 'Sovereignty should be respected'
"
data-check-event-based-preview=""
data-is-vertical-video-embed="false"
data-network-id=""
data-publish-date="2016-06-07T23:46:59Z"
data-video-section="world"
data-canonical-url="https://www.cnn.com/videos/world/2016/06/07/chinese-jet-intercept-air-force-plane-lkl.cnn"
data-branding-key=""
data-video-slug="Chinese jet intercept air force plane lkl"
data-first-publish-slug="Chinese jet intercept air force plane lkl"
data-video-tags="aircraft,armed forces,aviation and aerospace industry,business and industry sectors,business, economy and trade,defense departments,east china sea,government and public administration,government bodies and offices,international relations and national security,military,military aircraft,national security,surveillance and reconnaissance aircraft,us air force,us department of defense,us federal departments and agencies,us federal government"
data-details="">
Editor’s Note: William Burke-White is a professor of law and the director of Perry World House at the University of Pennsylvania. From 2009-2011, he served on Secretary of State Hillary Clinton’s policy planning staff at the U.S. Department of State. The views expressed in this commentary are his.
Story highlights
An international court has determined China's claims in the South China Sea violate international law
Professor William Burke-White: This decision will be a true test of whether the law can constrain Chinese power
CNN
—
The Permanent Court of Arbitration in the Hague has issued a scathing legal rebuke of China’s maritime claims in the South China Sea. This stunning decision pits the international legal order against the power of a rising China, with significant ramifications for both the international legal system and for the geopolitics of Southeast Asia. Whether law can constrain power now turns on how China, the United States and other countries in the region use the new decision.
Finding in favor of the Philippines, the court determined that China’s expansive claims in the region were a violation of the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, or UNCLOS, an international agreement that specifies the rights of states over the oceans and of which 166 countries are a party, including China.
China’s efforts to build islands far from its shores created no new legal rights, the court decided, and deemed illegal China’s military efforts to exclude the Philippines and other nations from fishing in the region.
China sought to avoid the dispute, refusing to send representatives to appear in person and challenging the legal right of the court to exercise jurisdiction in the case, arguing that the case related to territorial rights outside the court’s powers, rather than the maritime rights over which the court has jurisdiction.
To a large degree, international legal efforts to accommodate the rise of China have been based on avoiding direct legal conflict where possible and allowing politics and diplomacy to take their natural course. Had the court accepted the Chinese position on jurisdiction, the conflict between law and power that now arises could have been put off to another day.
The court’s findings – both that it has the power to decide the case and that China’s claims are illegal – mark the first significant international legal confrontation with a rising China. It is a bold move by the court, one that pits the authority and legitimacy of the legal institutions created by the post-World War II international order against the political and economic might of China. The question now is how both sides will respond. The answer will be more significant than the ruling itself.
Will China accept the legal principles on which the decision is based? These principles are, in fact, in China’s long-term interests, as they offer the best prospect for the avoidance of a military conflict in the region consistent with China’s peaceful rise. China need not accept them openly or publicly, but it can do so through a gradual change in its rhetoric and behavior.
For example, it can tone down its claims to legal rights that flow from created islands or tidal rock formations in the region. While still patrolling international waters, China can be more accommodating of other countries’ fishing vessels in the region. More dramatically, China could even slow down its construction of military bases in the region.
Any of those moves in the coming months would be a tacit accommodation of the international legal system and a strong signal that China is ready to help uphold an international legal system that broadly serves its interests.
However, China may decide to take a more confrontational stance, rejecting not only the court’s jurisdiction but also the underlying legal principles of UNCLOS. We will know China has taken this course if it steps up its military activities in the South China Sea, expands its island-building efforts and adopts an even more aggressive tone in its relations with the Philippines, Vietnam and other countries in the region.
Of course, China can ignore the decision, but doing so would be counterproductive. China’s success in persuading states in the region to recognize and follow its leadership depends on China’s reputation as a rule follower, not a rule breaker, as a source of economic opportunity, not security threats. Undercutting legal principles will not actually increase China’s already extraordinary influence in the region, because ignoring the court’s decision outright works counter to China’s critical leadership objective by feeding growing regional fear of China.
The challenge presented by Tuesday’s decision for the international system more generally is that the decision on which course to take is, essentially, China’s alone. The Permanent Court of Arbitration has no meaningful enforcement mechanism, and neither the United Nations nor other countries in the region have the military ability to limit China’s activities in the region.
What international actors and countries in the region can do is embrace the principles underlying the ruling without demanding immediate change. Demanding compliance with the ruling risks undermining the authority of international law itself if China continues its present course. If, however, other states and institutions embrace the broad principles of law in the ruling, while giving China the room to more gradually modify its behavior and scale back its claims, both political stability in the region and the salience of international law can be preserved.
Here, the lesson of the ruling for the United States is, perhaps, most obvious of all. The United States has refused to join UNCLOS, even after a strong push to do so early in the Obama administration. The U.S. Senate was concerned that UNCLOS would constrain the United States and limit U.S. actions in the seas. However, this decision shows that international law, including UNCLOS, is and will be a critical tool not for constraining the United States, but for ensuring that established and rising powers alike operate within a common legal framework that serves collective interests.
The United States is sure to invoke the findings of the court in its future patrols of the South China Sea. Doing so as a member of UNCLOS would dramatically change U.S. legitimacy and effectiveness in enforcing the court’s ruling.
William Burke-White is a professor of law and the director of Perry World House at the University of Pennsylvania. From 2009-2011, he served on Secretary of State Hillary Clinton’s policy planning staff at the U.S. Department of State. The views expressed in this commentary are his.